| 1917 - 1918 | Independent |
| 1919 - 1922 | University Methodist Church |
| 1923 - 1925 | First United Presbyterian Church |
| 1926 - | The American Legion |
| 1927 - 1939 | First United Presbyterian Church |
| 1940 - 1942 | Society of the Sons of the Revolution |
| 1943 - 1949 | Society of the Sons of the Revolution Episcopal Church of the Holy Communion |
| 1950 - 1954 | Episcopal Church of the Holy Communion |
| 1955 - 1964 | University Methodist Church |
| 1965 - | Salem-in-Ladue Methodist Church |