Order of the Arrow
| 1943 | Dave Barnes |
| | Joe McClain |
| 6-28-47 | Dick Barnes |
| | Guy Miller |
| 7- 5-47 | Nelson Baker |
| 8- 7-48 | Bob Robbins |
| | Bill Shoop |
| 8- 6-49 | Verne Barnhart |
| | Mike Maremont |
| | JackTaylor |
| | |
| 7-29-50 | John Shoop |
| 8- 5-50 | Mike Kiernan |
| | Bill Lichty |
| 6-23-51 | Andy Lindquist |
| | Tom Barnes |
| 8-23-52 | Bob Barnes |
| | Hal Smith |
| | Ken Underwood |
| 8-21-54 | Irwin Albrecht |
| | John Honefinger |
| | Alex Smith |
| 8-13-55 | Roger Fisher |
| | Bruce Swaine |
| | Gerry Swango |
| 8-17-57 | Richard Frank |
| | Tom Wilson |
| 8- 8-58 | Steve Albrecht |
| | Tom Kikis |
| | Jim Landau |
| 8-14-59 | Paul Harrington |
| | Dave Taylor |
| | Jim Wion |
| |
| 8-19-60 | Fred Eppenberger |
| | Dick Epstein |
| | Bill Klamon |
| 8-16-62 | Ricky Albrecht |
| | Doug Taylor |
| | Tim Arnold |
| | Marshall Goldberg |
| 8- 8-63 | Bob Eskridge |
| | Reed Hammond |
| 7- 2-64 | Alec Arnold |
| | Bill Eskridge |
| | Dan Taylor |
| 8-12-65 | Peat Hammond |
| | Bruce Madison |
| | Steve Madison |
| | Bob Sorensen |
| |
| |
| 8-18-66 | Larry Weidle |
| | Don Hardwick |
| | Tom Kiernan |
| 8-17-67 | Ken Skaggs |
| | Louis Magyar |
| | Bob Werner |
| 8- 8-68 | Carr Trovillion |
| | Matt McGoogan |
| | Dave Madison |
| | Steve Marx |
| 6-19-69 | Ricky Barnhart |
| | Tom McClure |
| | Dave Marx |
| 6-18-70 | Flip Albrecht |
| | Paul Jacoby |
| | Butch Weidle |
| | Lincoln Mayer |
| | Scott Siegerist |
| 6-17-71 | Jim Barnes |
| | Craig Siegerist |
| | Bill Nichols |
| | Mike Werner |
| 8- 3-72 | Robert Albrecht |
| | Mike Magyar |
| | Jim Callahan |
| 8- 2-73 | George Koors |
| | Tom Meek |
| 8- 1-74 | Scott Ramsey |
| | Keith Ramsey |
| | Barrett Thiele |
| 8- 1-75 | Jack Trovillion |
| | David Ferguson |
| | Ken WIlliamson |
| 7-29-76 | John Berger |
| | Charles Koors |
| | Paul Ruland |
| | Dennis Swaine |
| | Mike Bettonville |
| | Sam Clude |
| | Greg Mitsunaga |
| 7-28-77 | Tim Magary |
| | Tony Burke |
| | Bill Weber |
| | Gary Steiner |
| | Joe Nusrala |
| | Scott Shepard |
| 7-27-78 | Brad Shepard |
| | Bobby Barnes |
| 7-30-79 | Mike Harrell |
| | Tommy Barnes |
| | Steve Green |
| | Philip Pritzker |
| | Breck Reay |
| | Ray Young |
|
| 7-24-80 | Dan Sharpe |
| | Marc Sokol |
| | Geoff George |
| 7-30-81 | Quentin Wildsmith |
| | Doug Sharpe |
| | Tom Maloney |
| | Tom Cullinane |
| 1982 | below under construction |
| 1983 | |
| 1984 | Brent Flachsbart |
| 1985 | |
| 1986 | |
| 1987 | |
| 1988 | |
| 1989 | Josh Cope |
| | Matt Bruns |
| ? | Jay Newman |
| ? | Tom Cannon |
| ? | Todd Greenstein |
| ? | Scott Smilth |
| | Matt Jaworski |
|
| above under construction |
| 1990 | David Bruns |
| | Justin Wildsmith |
| 1991 | Ryan Dugger |
| | Ryan Gregg |
| 1992 | James Farmer |
| | Eric Schaefer |
| 1993 | Russell Ball |
| | Aaron Kaufman |
| | Eric Johnson |
| 1994 | John Dugger |
| | Mike Johnson |
| | Tony Sheata |
| | Matt Shepard |
| 1995 | Brad Baebler |
| | Justin Ball |
| | Penn Boon |
| | David Johnson |
| 1996 | William Fox |
| | Andy Lynch |
| 1997 | Logan Henderson |
| | Philip Henderson |
| | Erich Kiehl |
| 1998 | Dolph Spoeneman |
| | Rhett Seisener |
| 1999 | Landon Boehm |
| | Daniel Bond |
| | James Bornfleth |
| | Andrew Brenner |
| | Anthony Scodary |
| | Michael Sullivan |
| 2000 | Reed Brown |
| | Ryker Bornfleth |
| | Chris Fava |
| | Paul Kiehl |
| 2001 | Ian Hermann |
| | Tyler Thompson |
| 2002 | Cody Boehm |
| | Logan Brown |
| 2003 | Curran Coulter |
| | Eric Fiedler |
| | Matt Fiedler |
| | Nick Scodary |
| 2004 | Tim Richarz |
| | Doug Stream |
| | Ben Williams |
| 2005 | Daniel George |
| | Michael Gorin |
| 2006 | Jeff Fox |
| | Eric Mullis |
| | Brian Sableman |
| 2007 | Drew Tyler |
| | David Mullis |
| 2008 | Brink Thompson |
| | Kevin Ramsey |
| 2009 | Thomas Van Horn |
| | Scott Van Horn |
| 2010 | Nikith Rao |
| | Jasnaam Grewal |
| | Andres Rodriguez |
| 2011 | Andrew Weidle |
| | Evan Richards |
(date = date of tapout/callout)